The BBC has yet to name a successor to Monty Don as the main presenter of BBC Gardeners’ World, but audience reactions already point to a strong preference for who could step into the role. Don, who has led the programme for 23 years—including 16 at his Longmeadow garden—officially announced his final season through an Instagram post on September 8.
In the message, he expressed gratitude for fan support, writing: “They were encouraging, they were moving, they were kind, they were embarrassing… it was fabulous.” He stressed that he is not retiring. “I am leaving Gardeners’ World, but I’ve got other projects on the go.”
The news prompted widespread nostalgia, with many viewers acknowledging that no one could fully replace him.
One comment captured the sentiment: “Monty Don is Gardeners’ World. He’s like an old friend that you have just dropped in to see. I wish him well for the future but will miss him.” Others shared similar thoughts, noting they would miss not just Don but also his garden and his dog, Ned, who had become a beloved on-screen companion.
Fan Favorite Replacements Emerge for *Gardeners’ World*
Despite the emotional response, viewers have already formed clear opinions about potential replacements. The most frequently mentioned candidate was Adam Frost, with many fans declaring him their top choice. One person commented: “If only one person, then definitely Adam Frost.” Another echoed these thoughts, saying: “Adam Frost would be my first choice please.” Frost’s recent move to a larger property, which requires significant garden work, has fueled speculation about his suitability. One person on Instagram said: “Just by chance Adam’s just bought a new house with a garden which needs a complete overhaul.
Read Also: Best Gardens Shortlisted for 2027 Designers Awards
Funny that.”
Other strong contenders included Frances Tophill, Jamie Butterworth, and Carol Klein. One person said: “I would love to see someone young and enthusiastic take over the role. Jamie Butterworth would be perfect!” Many mentions were also given to Arit Anderson, Joe Swift, Sue Kent, and Rachel de Thame. Some suggested that a newbie would be welcome, with people highlighting the likes of garden designer and influencer Henry Agg. There was even a suggestion that designer Dan Pearson, who announced the closure of his design studio in the same week, might be a new presenter.
An alternative proposal gaining traction was the idea of rotating presenters rather than appointing a single successor. Fans suggested this approach could rejuvenate the programme by offering diverse perspectives. One follower said: “I hope it’s a few, I love a variety of the different approaches. Perhaps it’s time for a more balanced approach so not one person has the pressure of sharing their life with the camera.” Others said that reshuffling the current presenters wouldn’t be enough to breathe new life into Gardeners’ World, suggesting that some new faces and fresh ideas wouldn’t go amiss.
One person on Facebook said: “Monty’s done a great job for a very long time…but the show needs a refresh with some new people.”
Beyond professional qualifications, viewers also considered personal appeal, such as on-screen charm. Don’s dogs, Nigel, Nell, Patti, and Ned, have long been a fan-favorite element of the show, with one audience member calling them “truly essential for a happy life.” Presenters like Frances Tophill and Jamie Butterworth received praise for their own pets, which could similarly enhance viewer engagement. Even Jeremy Clarkson contributed to the debate in The Sunday Times, recommending the BBC select someone “safe and relaxing to watch” and naming gardening influencer Chloe from Blooms & Greens as his preferred choice.
Why Monty’s Exit Sparks Debate Over Show’s Future
The BBC has not yet revealed a replacement, but the volume of fan suggestions highlights the programme’s lasting cultural significance. Don’s departure creates an opening, yet the discussions about potential successors demonstrate the show’s continued influence. For now, audiences remain optimistic that the next presenter will combine expertise with charisma to fill the Friday-night time slot effectively.
